McGrathNicol, which has been appointed administrator of David Jones, will investigate whether the department store group was insolvent before administrators were placed in charge, as receivers ready plans to shut about half the chain’s locations across Australia and New Zealand.
“Our investigations will look at when the company might have been insolvent, if that was a date prior to the date of appointment of administrators.”
Creditors were told at a recent meeting that suppliers, concession holders and lenders together are owed about $400 million, and tensions flared over allegations some suppliers received preferential payments while the business was struggling.
Administrators are already setting aside substantial sums for their fees, while employees are guaranteed claims for entitlements totalling about $11 million. About 1,500 staff are expected to be made redundant and the union has negotiated that employees with nine years’ service will receive 16 weeks pay.
Two secured lenders sit ahead of most other creditors: Hilco, the receiver manager, claims $115 million and Anchorage Capital has registered a secured loan of $80 million. Both security registrations occurred in September, less than two months before the company’s collapse.
McGrathNicol told creditors it will examine the history and validity of those facilities and report back, and administrators noted they first discussed restructuring options with the David Jones board in July after evidence of cash flow pressure emerged earlier in the year.
Under one scenario, challenging the validity of the secured loans or any preferential payments would fold Hilco and Anchorage into the same pool as unsecured suppliers and concession holders, who together are owed about $180 million. That would improve unsecured creditors’ prospects, but only if legal challenges succeed and liquidation proceeds allow for recovery.
The David Jones business had been loss-making under previous owner Woolworths in 2022, with several expensive leases flagged as unsustainable. Anchorage acquired the group in 2023 with $55 million of its own equity, a $40 million loan, and then used about $150 million of the retailer’s cash flow to help fund a $250 million store rejuvenation plan promised by former chief executive Scott Fyfe, who left in June and has since disputed aspects of his family’s stake.
Concession holders told administrators they are being treated as unsecured for recent sales that David Jones collected on their behalf, a classification that has prompted talk of litigation and potential class actions if they recover nothing. Small suppliers reported little confidence of recovery: one homewares co-founder owed $75,000 said he did not expect to get anything back.
McGrathNicol said it cannot yet estimate likely returns to creditors and that any figure will depend on the outcome of the sale process; the administrators expect to provide more clarity in a creditors report most likely due in early February. Receivers appointed by secured creditor Hilco will continue to manage the trading business while that process unfolds.
